Rank the seasons.

[vgaddict]

How would you, personally, rank the seasons of the show, from best to worst?

[rocketman]

Sure.

The best: ALL of them.

But! I'm partial to TV's Frank and black-and-white movies. So I guess seasons 1-6 and the first half of 8 have a slight personal edge over the rest.

[Torgo]

Personally I'm going to wait until I've reviewed every episode on my blog before I try my definitive ranking of seasons. I'm pretty sure seasons 7 and 8 are my favorites though. And I think I have 1 on the bottom, lower than KTMA even.

I haven't even tried to figure out where the new seasons go yet.

[hike'em'up]

Dec 17, 2018 11:54:16 GMT -5 Torgo said:

I haven't even tried to figure out where the new seasons go yet.

I'm not even going to bother including them. Feel like they are to be judged among themselves and not compared to the superior originals. Seems unfair.
Also not going to include Season 1 for similar reasons; it's almost it's own separate show.  Just assume it's at the bottom of the list.

1 - Season 3:  four of my Top 10 and 8 of my Top 25 are here. rewatching endlessly for the confirmation bias.
2 - Season 5:  pivotal season for the show, obviously. two Top 10 and six Top 25. the 505-513 stretch is the best of the entire series.
3 - Season 8:  episodes take a hit for the serious downturn in host segments. still some highlights with four Top 25 eps.
4 - Season 2:  shortened season but still manages three Top 10 episodes, including numbers 1 & 2 for me
5 - Season 4:  probably the most disappointing season. a lot of filler episodes but a strong finish.
6 - Season10: enjoyed the closure, on top of managing a handful of respectful episodes to go out with.
7 - Season 7:  included the movie and they made every episode in this season count. not a single, really bad one.
8 - Season 9:  the writing on the wall season. and i dont think as highly of 'Werewolf' as others do.
9 - Season 6:  similar to Season 4, except with Mike instead of Joel and minus the high notes.

[leeharveyosmond]

5 > 7 > 6 > 8 > 2 > 10 > 4 > 9 > 3 > 1

[Mighty Jack]

5, 8, 7, 6 are my favorites... not sure where I'd slot the rest. But those 4 are my golden seasons.

[enderpotato00]

7, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 4, 3, 2, 1, 12, 11

[Caedmon]

Off the top of my head:


Season 5

Season 4

Season 3

Season 7

Season 8

Season 6

Season 10

Season 9

Season 11

Season 2

Season 12

Season 1

Seasons 3-5 are pretty much dead even for me.