Guess what it is....

[otrfan]

Okay, I'm bored, so here is a game....

An old pickup truck just drove by out in front of where I work. It didn't have a tailgate so something fell out of the bed and landed in the gutter in front of where I work. Your job is to guess what it is.

I will reveal the answer in approximately one hour, unless someone actually guesses it before then.

I will only answer YES or NO questions as to what it is.

This really happened about 10 minutes ago so I'm not making it up. Thank you and good luck!

[Phantom Engineer]

OK, my question is...
Do I care?

[marytrobot]

a tree branch

[otrfan]

tree branch: NO

I can't answer phantom's question, only he knows the answer to that one.

[marytrobot]

ohoh EYEBALLS!

[Phantom Engineer]

A case of Hamdingers.

[otrfan]

eyeballs: NO (but, amazingly, part of your answer is right )
hamdingers: NO

[marytrobot]

a dead dear

[Phantom Engineer]

otrfan said:

eyeballs: NO (but, amazingly, part of your answer is right )
hamdingers: NO

The Crawling Eye!

[Phantom Engineer]

No wait, my guess is a big steamin' pile of Who Cares!

[otrfan]

a dead deer: NO

[Ator]

Can we get a hint? I'm gonna guess a barrell, or a box of something.

[Phantom Engineer]

otrfan said:

a dead deer: NO

I'm sorry, she said dead "dear."

[otrfan]

a barrel: NO
a box of something: NO
a dead deer or dear: NO and NO
The Crawling Eye: NO

[Phantom Engineer]

Jimmy Hoffa. I knew he'd turn up.